Got extra Magic cards collecting dust in a binder or box? We want them! Storming Good Games is officially buying Magic: The Gathering singles through our Buy List—and we’d love to help you turn your collection into something new.
Whether you’re looking to cash out some old staples, make room in your collection, or trade up for new decks, we’re here to help. We offer competitive pricing and flexible options: choose cash or get extra value in store credit toward singles, sealed product, or accessories.
How it Works:
Bring your cards to any of our events—like Monday Night Commander pop-up shop at The Bodega—and we’ll take a look right on the spot. For larger collections, reach out to us in advance and we’ll set up a time to review everything with care.
📦 What We Buy
-
Magic: The Gathering Singles – Standard, Modern, Commander, Legacy, and Vintage staples
-
Bulk Cards – Commons, uncommons, rares, and mythics
-
Sealed Product – Boosters, decks, and boxes (sealed only)
-
Entire Collections – Reach out for a personalized quote
💰 How We Price Singles
Our buylist pricing is based on real-time demand and market data. We use TCGPlayer sales and market pricing to ensure you're getting a fair, competitive offer.
🔁 Demand-Based Tiers
We adjust our buy prices based on how quickly a card is currently selling on TCGPlayer:
| Daily Sales Volume | Card Demand | Our Offer (% of Market Price*) |
|---|---|---|
| 50+ sales/day | Very High | Up to 75% of Market |
| 20–49 | High | 60–65% of Market |
| 5–19 | Moderate | 50–55% of Market |
| 1–4 | Low | 40–45% of Market |
| 0 | Very Low | Bulk pricing or declined |
* We define “Market Price” using the latest available data from TCGPlayer’s Market or Direct Low prices.
🧼 Condition Guidelines
All cards must be English, tournament-legal, and unsleeved. We accept the following conditions:
| Condition | Offer |
|---|---|
| Near Mint (NM) | Full buy price |
| Lightly Played (LP) | -10% |
| Moderately Played (MP) | -20% |
| Heavily Played / Damaged | Not accepted unless rare or highly sought-after |
📦 Bulk Card Rates
We offer competitive rates on bulk cards — perfect for clearing out your collection’s clutter!
-
Bulk Rares (NM, English): $0.10–$0.15 each
-
Bulk Mythics: $0.25–$0.30 each
-
Bulk Commons/Uncommons:
-
$3 per 1,000 (non-sorted)
-
$5 per 1,000 (sorted by color)
-
Cards must be in good condition and from legal Magic sets. No basic lands, tokens, or damaged cards.
Storming Good Games
Building community one card at a time.